Monthly plan check · September 2026 · live SolaX data
This month's read — rebuilt on your real meter data
The demand charge is costing about $744 a year, and it turns a competitive-looking plan into the most expensive option on the table.
Your inverter's half-hourly grid readings put your annual electricity bill near $2,228 — roughly $330 above the reference price, on only 3,406 kWh of grid import. The same import on a flat-rate offer with no demand component comes in around $1,160–$1,250. Gas is still worth about $310, and the feed-in about $54 a year at 3c.
Your solar and battery already cover nearly two thirds of the house. The problem is not how much you buy — it's when, and how hard.
One-off welcome credits of $200 on electricity and $200 on gas apply to your first bills, plus a year of complimentary NRMA membership. Those are first-year only — the comparison below is on ongoing rates, which is what matters from bill three onward.
Wait for the credits. It costs about $50, and the calendar is on your side.
September and October are the two months on this plan that carry no demand charge at all — the whole day is off-peak. Combined with light winter-end import and strong spring export, staying with ENGIE through them costs roughly $135 against $85 on the cheapest flat-rate offer. Fifty dollars to collect four hundred.
The three-month mark from your 31 July acceptance falls at the end of October — which is also the last moment before the demand charge restarts on 1 November. From then it runs about $89 a month through to March. Leaving in the first week of November captures the credits and skips the entire summer demand season; every week past that costs real money.
| Window | Demand charge | Cost of staying on ENGIE |
|---|---|---|
| Sep – Oct 2026 | None — off-peak months | ~$50 total |
| End Oct 2026 | Credits secured. Switch here. | |
| Nov 2026 – Mar 2027 | High season, 151 days | ~$89 per month |
Confirm both credits have actually landed before giving notice — the electricity one arrives on your first bill, but gas transfers can take up to 90 days to complete, so the gas credit may run later than the electricity one. Check the terms of the credit offer for how the three months is counted: from acceptance, from supply start, or from first bill.
| Component | Annual | Share | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Demand charge | $744 | 33% | Your worst half-hour each month × every day of that month |
| Peak usage | $632 | 28% | 2,040 kWh at 30.99c — 75% of your import lands in 3–9pm |
| Supply charge | $580 | 26% | 158.90c/day, payable whether you use anything or not |
| Off-peak usage | $327 | 15% | 1,366 kWh at 23.91c |
| Feed-in credit | −$54 | — | 1,800 kWh exported at 3c |
| Total | $2,228 | 100% | About $557 a quarter |
Usage is only 43% of this bill. Two fixed-ish charges — supply and demand — account for $1,324 a year before you switch anything on.
| Month | Peak demand | Set at | Days billed | Charge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| January | 6.40 kW | 10 Jan, 5:00pm | 31 | $86 |
| February | 7.40 kW | 26 Feb, 5:30pm | 28 | $90 |
| March | 6.44 kW | 15 Mar, 8:00pm | 31 | $87 |
| June | 6.20 kW | 29 Jun, 6:00pm | 30 | $81 |
| July | 6.28 kW | 25 Jul, 6:30pm | 31 | $85 |
| August | 10.16 kW | 26 Aug, 6:30pm | 31 | $137 |
| Nov & Dec | ~6.75 kW | no meter data yet | 61 | $179 |
April, May, September and October carry no demand charge — the whole day is off-peak. The single half-hour on 26 August cost about $40 more than an ordinary evening would have; nothing else you did that month mattered to the charge.
You were right — it fills up and you use the lot. That's exactly the problem.
On a good day the battery reaches 100% and discharges hard into the night, and the grid barely registers. On the days that set your demand charge, the household simply out-eats it: 14.4 kWh against a median day of 28 kWh, and against 41–141 kWh on the six days that actually set a peak. It empties, and the grid takes the rest of the evening at full household power.
Three days, same axes. Charge on the left, what you bought from the grid on the right. The shaded band is the 3–9pm window where demand is priced.
What the three days show. On 5 January the battery hit 100%, ran the evening down to its floor by 10pm, and the worst half-hour off the grid was 1.2 kW. On 10 January the sun was better still — 44.1 kWh generated — but the house drew 88.6 kWh, so the battery never got past 51%, floored at 5pm, and the grid took 7.2 kW half an hour later. On 26 August the panels made 13.2 kWh against a 48.2 kWh load; the battery never cleared 16% and the grid hit 10.6 kW.
So it isn't a power limit — it discharges at 3.7–5.0 kW right up to the moment it runs out, and 5,040 W was measured on 29 June. It is an energy limit meeting a household that uses two to ten times the battery's capacity in a day.
| If grid draw were held under | Demand charge | Saved | Net of overnight charging |
|---|---|---|---|
| Today — uncapped | $744 | — | — |
| 2 kW | $211 | $533 | $447 |
| 3 kW | $317 | $427 | $341 |
| 4 kW | $422 | $322 | $236 |
| 5 kW | $528 | $216 | $130 |
The demand charge only needs the single worst half-hour of each month covered — about 2.5 kWh at 5 kW. The battery has 14.4. The problem is allocation, not capacity: it spends everything on daytime self-consumption and has nothing left at 6pm. Holding back a few kWh for 3–9pm, and topping up overnight at the off-peak rate on days that need it, is the whole fix. Overnight charging sits outside the window, so it creates no demand charge of its own.
This is a setting in the SolaX app, not a purchase: Peak Shaving mode if the inverter offers it, otherwise a TOU work-mode schedule reserving a minimum state of charge across 3–9pm with scheduled off-peak grid charging. I took read-only API access deliberately, so I can measure what the battery does but cannot change how it behaves.
A 49.71c peak rate, on a household that buys 75% of its power in the peak window. This is the worst shape match on the page.
Tesla's Australian plan prices Ausgrid at 49.71c/kWh from 3–9pm and 24.02c/kWh the rest of the day — and unlike your ENGIE tariff, that peak window appears to run year-round, with no April/May/September/October exemption. Your off-peak rate would improve slightly. Your peak rate would rise from 30.99c to 49.71c on roughly 2,550 kWh a year.
| Component | Rate | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Peak, 3–9pm (Ausgrid) | 49.71 c/kWh | Published |
| Off-peak, 9pm–3pm | 24.02 c/kWh | Published |
| Daily supply charge | — | Not published — $1.10 assumed below |
| Export credit | 90% of wholesale | Dynamic, no floor — modelled below at ~$80/yr |
| Grid Services Credit | — | Powerwall FCAS only, no rate card |
| Powerwall or Tesla vehicle required? | — | Unclear |
| Sign-up credit, term, exit fee | — | Not published |
The $1.10/day supply charge is my assumption, not Tesla's figure. Tesla has published no daily charge at all — I used $1.10 because Ausgrid market offers run 92c–147c, and the total needs some number in that slot. Swap in 92c and the estimate falls to about $1,738; swap in 147c and it rises to about $1,939. The 4c average export capture is likewise mine. At 65–80% peak share the range is $1,716–$1,848 at $1.10/day. Treat every Tesla figure on this page as provisional until that one line is published.
Don't confuse this with Tesla's previous Australian offer. The Tesla Energy Plan, run with Energy Locals, paired time-of-use rates with up to five years of extra Powerwall warranty and bill credits of up to $220 a year for batteries joining Tesla's virtual power plant. That plan closed on 30 September 2025 and its benefits do not carry over — the new Dynamic plan publishes no sign-up credit, no warranty benefit and no VPP payment beyond an unquantified Powerwall FCAS credit.
The trap is using the all-day average wholesale price. Your exports land at midday, which is the cheapest part of the day — so the number that matters is the solar-weighted price. IPART publishes exactly that for NSW, and it is the right yardstick here.
| Basis | c/kWh | ×90% | On 1,800 kWh |
|---|---|---|---|
| IPART 2026–27 NSW solar benchmark — low | 3.4 | 3.06 | $55 |
| IPART 2026–27 NSW solar benchmark — high | 6.5 | 5.85 | $105 |
| For contrast: NSW Q2-2026 all-day average spot ($75/MWh) | 7.5 | 6.75 | $121 |
| Ausgrid evening window, 4–9pm (IPART) | 17.2–18.7 | 15.5–16.8 | — |
Realistic band: $55–$105 a year, call it $80. That is roughly what a 4.5c flat feed-in would pay — better than your current 3c, worse than GloBird's 6c, and well short of a solid 8–12c offer. IPART's benchmark fell from 4.8–7.3c last year because more homes export at once; and NSW spot averaged $75/MWh in Q2 2026, down 53% year on year to a six-year low. So this estimate is drawn from an unusually cheap market — the credit could rise, but the downside has no floor, which a flat tariff does.
The evening row is the one genuinely attractive number, and it is a trap on this plan. A kWh you export at 6pm earns about 16c. The same kWh kept at home avoids a 49.71c import. Self-consumption wins better than three to one, so the right move under Tesla would be to hoard the battery, not trade with it — which is the same thing you should be doing anyway, without the 49.71c peak rate attached.
If you fix the battery first and cut peak import to ~800 kWh, Tesla lands near $1,353 — better than ENGIE-fixed (~$1,801) but still behind GloBird's flat rate at $1,160, which doesn't care what time you buy. A dynamic plan only beats a cheap flat rate if you actively arbitrage the export side, and your 14.4 kWh battery is already fully committed to self-consumption. Worth re-checking once the supply charge and eligibility are published; not worth acting on now.
| Retailer | Usage | Supply | Est. annual | vs you |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ENGIE — your plan | 3.64–5.90c/MJ | 57.23c | $1,123 | — |
| GloBird Energy | 3.73c/MJ | 58.69c | $810 | −$313 |
| Dodo | 4.76c/MJ | 42.01c | $859 | −$264 |
| Alinta Energy | 4.62c/MJ | 57.99c | $930 | −$193 |
| Kogan Energy | 3.47c/MJ | 77.39c | $976 | −$147 |
| Powershop | 3.85c/MJ | 85.30c | $980 | −$143 |
Your figure is modelled on your four daily blocks with winter-weighted consumption; the others are the retailers' published annual estimates at the same benchmark. Block pricing means a low headline rate can still cost more — Kogan's 3.47c/MJ is the cheapest usage rate on this list and the fourth-cheapest bill.
| Retailer | Feed-in range | On your 1,800 kWh exported |
|---|---|---|
| Amber Electric | 4–25c/kWh | Wholesale-linked, subscription fee applies |
| Origin Energy | 3–22c/kWh | Top rates capped to the first few kWh/day |
| Energy Locals | 5–15c/kWh | up to $270/yr |
| ENGIE — other plans | 6–11c/kWh | $108–$198/yr |
| ENGIE — your plan | 3.00c/kWh | $54/yr |
High headline feed-in rates are usually capped at a daily kWh limit and paired with higher usage rates — the sensible target is a solid 8–12c uncapped, not the biggest number advertised. Worth one call to ENGIE: moving to a better feed-in plan with the same retailer avoids a transfer entirely. Keep this in proportion though: at 1,800 kWh exported, the whole feed-in question is worth about a tenth of the demand charge.
A note on the numbers: your monthly peak demand is measured from your inverter's own grid readings at 5-minute resolution, aggregated to clock half-hours. Ausgrid meters the same quantity, so the two should agree closely — but check one against a real ENGIE bill before acting on the largest figure here. November and December have no meter history yet and are estimated from your January–March peaks.